Loading... Please wait...
How to help your child choose: what happens at instrument tryout night, and what each instrument really asks of lips, teeth, hands, backpacks, wallets and the people at home.
The short answer
- First, go to tryout night and check the band director's list. The director knows which sections have room, and the list tells you what features to look for. Buy after that meeting.
- Easiest first sound: alto sax, also the biggest and heaviest of the four.
- Best all-rounder on a budget: clarinet. Affordable and light; it needs fingers big enough to seal open holes, and fresh reeds every few weeks.
- Lightest and gentlest with braces: flute, though the first sound takes the most patience.
- Loud, bold and low-cost to keep: trumpet, the toughest to start with braces.
- If your child loves one already, that matters more than anything below.
Most kids start band in fourth to sixth grade, usually on one of these four. All are good first instruments; they differ in the mouth, the hands, the costs and the noise. For renting, buying and supplies, see our school band guide for parents.
Start here: the director's list and tryout night
Most school bands hold an instrument tryout night before band starts. A band director meets each child one-on-one, and your child tries several instruments, usually their top three. One middle school says most students finish in 20–30 minutes, and that directors look at hand size, comfort and breath support. They also look at lips, teeth and jaw, because each instrument uses a different embouchure, the way the lips shape around the mouthpiece.
Wait for this night before you buy. Some sections fill fast, and one Texas district puts it plainly: "Please do not buy an instrument before we meet with you!" Afterwards, check the director's supply list. Most lists describe features, like closed holes and offset G on a flute, which our flutes have, plus the reeds, oil and books each child needs.
Keep it in proportion, though. Bret Pimentel, a college woodwind teacher, argues a few minutes of testing can't predict success, and that "motivation is the make-or-break factor for beginning instrumentalists." We agree. A child who loves their instrument practices more.
The four compared
Rent is the typical monthly rate from two music-store price lists (see Sources).
| Instrument | First sound | With braces | Hands & reach | Typical weight | Ongoing costs | At home | Rent / month | Our starter pick |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Flute | Hardest to start | Easiest: no mouthpiece pressed on teeth | Arms reach sideways; small kids may need a curved head | about 1.1 lb | Low: no reeds | Bright and piercing up high | $22–25 | Levante LV-FL5111 $529.99 |
| Clarinet | Some squeaks at first | Usually fine after a few weeks | Fingers must seal open holes | light | Reeds, cork grease | Moderate; squeaks early on | $22–25 | Stagg WS-CL210S $266.99 |
| Trumpet | Hardest brass to start | Hardest: lips press braces onto teeth | Easy: three valves, one hand | about 2.4 lb | Low: valve oil | Loudest of the four | $343.99 | Stagg LV-TR5205 $343.99 |
| Alto sax | Easiest to start | Usually fine after a few weeks | Keys cover every hole; big stretch for small hands | about 4.3 lb | Reeds, and the priciest servicing | Loud and full | $959.99 | Levante LV-AS4105 $959.99 |
A word on price before you shop
Student band instruments cover a wide price range. At two large band retailers today, a name-brand student flute lists at $1,322, a clarinet at $1,431, a trumpet at $1,869 and an alto sax at $3,396.
We sell affordable student instruments from Stagg and Levante, Stagg's wind-instrument line. They carry the features beginners need: closed holes, offset G and split E on our flutes, stainless steel valves on our trumpets and cornet, 17 nickel-plated keys on our clarinet. Each comes in a case. They suit families who would rather own than rent. When it arrives, try it together: the keys or valves should move freely and your child should get a sound. For more, read How to Choose an Affordable Band Instrument That Plays Great.
Each instrument, one by one
Flute: light and gentle on braces, tricky to start
First sound. You blow across a hole, like over a bottle top. Many kids get only air for the first few days. One junior-high band guide rates flute the hardest instrument to start.
Lips and braces. The embouchure is a small, relaxed opening in the lips, and nothing presses on the teeth. The British Orthodontic Society says woodwind players tend to adjust to braces quickly. Of the four, flute is usually the gentlest.
Hands and reach. Holding it sideways with both arms out can strain small arms. A curved headjoint, a bent top section, shortens the reach; ask the director at tryout night whether your child needs one. Look for closed holes (solid keys, easier for beginners) and offset G (one key set out of line so the left hand sits naturally).
Carrying and costs. About 1.1 lb, and it fits in a backpack. No reeds. Hickey's lists a basic student flute service at $80.
At home. High notes carry through walls.
Our opinion, not science: flute often suits patient kids who like playing the tune.
Our pick. The Levante LV-FL5111 $529.99 ticks every beginner box: closed holes, offset G and a split E (a mechanism that makes one tricky high note easier). Its head, body and keys are nickel silver with silver plating, and the keys are French-style. It arrives lesson-ready with a soft case, swab, cloth and gloves. Its little sister, the Stagg WS-FL111, has the same key features. More in our flute guide.
Pros
- Lightest to carry
- Friendliest with braces
- No reeds to buy
Good to know
- The first sound takes a few days of patience
- Small kids may want a curved head for the sideways reach
- Often a popular section, so ask early about space
Clarinet: the affordable all-rounder
First sound. A thin cane reed vibrates against the mouthpiece. A sound comes easily; a clean one takes weeks.
Lips and braces. The lower lip rolls over the bottom teeth and the upper teeth rest on the mouthpiece. New braces can make the lower lip sore; orthodontic wax or a lip protector helps, and most kids settle in.
Hands and reach. This is the big one. Several holes are open, so the fingertips themselves must seal them. Small fingers leak air, and leaks squeak. Ask the director to check at tryout night.
Carrying and costs. It comes apart into five pieces in a small, light case. The running cost is reeds. Music & Arts sells a box of 10 Rico clarinet reeds for $24.99, and West Music suggests replacing most reeds after four weeks at most. Beginners crack a few too, so budget two or three boxes a year, roughly $50–75 (our estimate). Hickey's lists a basic student service at $80.
At home. Moderate. The early squeaks are the hard part.
Our opinion, not science: clarinet often suits steady, detail-minded kids.
Our pick. The Stagg WS-CL210S $266.99 is a Boehm-system clarinet (the standard fingering system taught in school band) with a brushed ABS body in a wood look, 17 solid-metal nickel-plated keys, 6 rings and an adjustable thumb holder. It comes with a mouthpiece, ligature and cap, a reed guard with a reed, a swab and a soft case with straps. We also carry the Levante LV-CL4100 and the lighter Stagg WS-CL110. Start on strength 2 to 2.5 reeds, like our Rico 3-pack $4.95, and add cork grease $4.95 for the joints. More in our clarinet guide.
Pros
- Affordable to start
- Light, compact case
- An easy move to sax later
Good to know
- Fingertips seal some holes, so ask the director to check hand size
- Expect a few squeaks in the first weeks
- Keep a spare pack of reeds on hand
Trumpet: bold, low-cost to keep, takes patience with braces
First sound. Brass players buzz their lips into a cup-shaped mouthpiece. Changing notes with the lips alone takes months. That junior-high guide calls trumpet the hardest brass instrument to start.
Lips and braces. The mouthpiece presses the lips onto the teeth, so braces hurt at first. The British Orthodontic Society says brass players may struggle with high notes soon after braces go on, and that most wind players adjust within a few months. That junior-high guide goes further: students in braces should not start trumpet. Mention planned braces at tryout night.
Hands and reach. The easiest of the four: three valves, one hand.
Carrying and costs. Yamaha's student trumpet weighs 1.09 kg (about 2.4 lb). No reeds, just valve oil and slide grease. A yearly chemical clean at Seattle Sound Repair is $95.
At home. The loudest of the four. A practice mute helps in the evening.
Our opinion, not science: trumpet often suits confident kids who don't mind being heard.
Our picks. The Stagg LV-TR5205 $343.99 has stainless steel valves, a gold brass leadpipe, a medium-large bore, a first-slide thumb saddle and a third-slide ring. It comes with a silver-plated 7C mouthpiece (the standard beginner size) and a soft case with straps, and Stagg lists a 2-year warranty on this model. If the director asks for a cornet, the trumpet's shorter, mellower cousin, the Stagg WS-CR215 $288.99 has stainless steel valves, an adjustable third-slide ring and a soft case with backpack straps; Stagg lists a 2-year warranty on it too. We also carry the Levante LV-TR4205 and Stagg WS-TR115. Add a Yamaha trumpet care kit $14.95. A pocket trumpet, like our Stagg WS-TR245S, is a fun travel and practice horn; for band class, directors expect a full-size B-flat trumpet. More in our trumpet guide.
Pros
- Simplest fingering
- Low-cost to keep
- Sturdy and easy to carry
Good to know
- Mention braces plans at tryout night
- A practice mute keeps evenings friendly
- Changing notes with the lips takes patience
Alto sax: easiest start, biggest investment
First sound. The easiest of the four. Many kids get a real note in the first minute.
Lips and braces. Like clarinet, with a slightly looser mouth: sore for a few weeks, then usually fine.
Hands and reach. Pads cover every hole, so there's nothing to seal. But the keys spread wide, a stretch for small hands.
Carrying and costs. About 4.3 lb on its own and about 11 lb in a hard case, a real load for a ten-year-old walking to school. A box of 10 Rico alto reeds is $30.99 at Music & Arts; budget roughly $60–95 a year (our estimate). Servicing costs most here: Hickey's lists a basic student service at $80, but a full repad at $525, against $270 for a clarinet.
At home. Loud and full.
Our opinion, not science: sax often suits outgoing kids drawn to jazz, pop and rock.
Our pick. The Levante LV-AS4105 $959.99 is a handsome first sax: brass body and neck, a hand-engraved bell, gold lacquer, a high F# key and an adjustable thumb rest. Leather pads with metal resonators give what its listing calls a "warm and brilliant sound". It comes with a mouthpiece, reed, ligature and cap in a soft case. For a sturdier ride on the bus, add our Stagg ABS alto sax case $132.99. We also carry the Stagg WS-AS215. Our Rico alto reedsSold out are a good start; any strength 2 to 2.5 alto reed will do. More in our alto sax guide.
Pros
- Fastest first sound
- No holes to seal
- Fun in jazz band later
Good to know
- The biggest investment of the four, so buying once pays off
- Heavier to carry; a case with straps helps
- The keys spread wide, so check the reach at tryout night
Two more common choices
Trombone. That junior-high guide rates it one of the easiest instruments to get a sound on, and bands are often short of trombones. The catch is arm length: the slide reaches out to seventh position, which many fourth and fifth graders can't reach yet, and teachers often leave it for later (Band Director Media Group). The Stagg WS-TB225 $374.99 is a small-bore (beginner-size) B-flat tenor slide trombone with chrome-plated inner slides, an 8.07" bell and a hard ABS case; Stagg lists a 2-year warranty on this model.
Percussion. Beginners learn drum and bells (a small metal keyboard); spots are often limited. Check the school's kit list; many want a snare drum. The Stagg bell set $247.99 has bells, a practice pad, stand, sticks and mallets in a gig bag, but no snare drum.
If your child… then consider…
- …is small for their age, or has small hands: flute (maybe with a curved headjoint) or trumpet. Be careful with clarinet holes and the sax stretch.
- …has braces, or will soon: flute first, then clarinet or sax. Talk to the director before choosing trumpet.
- …gets frustrated fast: alto sax or trombone, for the quick first sound.
- …walks or bikes to school: flute, clarinet or trumpet. An 11 lb sax case adds up.
- …lives in an apartment: flute or clarinet, or trumpet with a practice mute.
- …is on a tight budget: clarinet or trumpet, the most affordable to buy and keep.
Four mistakes to avoid
- Buying before tryout night. The section your child wants may already be full.
- Ignoring the braces calendar. Tell the director if braces are planned.
- Forgetting the running costs. Reeds, oil, a method book and a music stand $29.95 for home practice.
- Letting the first month decide. Everything sounds rough for weeks. Give it until winter break.
Common questions
- Which band instrument is easiest for a beginner?
- For a first sound, alto sax and trombone. Flute is usually the hardest to start. After the first month, practice matters far more.
- Should we rent or buy?
- Renting a flute, clarinet or trumpet typically costs $22–25 a month, and an alto sax about $37 (Hickey's and Nazareth Music publish rates in that range). That is $264–300 a year for a clarinet, about what our Stagg WS-CL210S $266.99 costs to own outright, and a year of alto sax rent is about $444. After that, the instrument you own keeps saving, and it can pass to a younger sibling. More in our school band guide.
- Is a curved-head flute worth it for a small child?
- If your child can't hold a regular flute without strain, yes. Kids usually switch to a straight head once their arms are long enough.
- Nimitz Middle School Band: Instrument Tryout Day FAQ (20–30 minutes, top three instruments, what directors look for)
- Lake Worth ISD: 5th Grade Beginning Band Information
- Bret Pimentel: The myth of beginning band instrument "tests"
- Hopkins Junior High Band (Greg Conway): How to Select an Instrument
- British Orthodontic Society: Advice for Musicians
- Dynamic Music Room: flute weight and saxophone weight
- Thomann: Yamaha YTR-2330 specifications (1.09 kg)
- Hickey's Music Center: rental price chart, Aug 2026 and woodwind repair prices
- Nazareth Music Center: rental rates
- Seattle Sound Repair: repair prices
- Music & Arts: Rico clarinet reeds, box of 10 and Rico alto sax reeds, box of 10
- West Music: When to change your woodwind reed
- Name-brand student-model prices: West Music YFL-222, Music & Arts YCL-255, West Music YTR-2330, Music & Arts YAS-26
- Band Director Media Group: Reaching the 7th trombone position